Skip to main content

1) Disclosure of MPs' Income Tax Returns | 10 August 2016

ADR sought information regarding the filing of Income Tax Returns (ITRs), copies of returns and assessment orders of 20 Lok Sabha MPs for 2004–2009. The CIC observed that the CPIOs had consulted only two MPs instead of all 20 under Section 11 of the RTI Act. It emphasised that the question of larger public interest must be examined alongside privacy considerations under Section 8(1)(j). The CIC directed the CPIOs to consult all concerned MPs, examine the larger public interest and pass reasoned, point-wise orders.

Judgment/Order

Date of issue

A Roadmap for the Complaint

6th May 2010

CIC order

10th August 2016

2) Non-compliance with CIC Order on Political Parties | 16 March 2015

The matter concerned non-compliance by six national political parties with the CIC's order dated 3 June 2013, declaring them public authorities under the RTI Act. The CIC observed that the parties had neither appointed CPIOs nor implemented the disclosure directions. It also acknowledged legal limitations in enforcing its orders, particularly the inability to impose penalties in the absence of designated CPIOs. The CIC declined to impose penalties or award compensation and referred the identified legal gaps to the Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT) for appropriate action.

Judgment/Order

Date of issue

CIC order on non-compliance

16th March 2015

3) Political Parties as Public Authorities under RTI | 3 June 2013

The matter concerned whether six national political parties could be classified as public authorities under Section 2(h) of the RTI Act. The CIC observed that political parties receive substantial indirect government financing and perform critical public functions in India's democratic system. Their significant role in governance and democratic institutions warrants transparency and accountability. Accordingly, the CIC declared INC, BJP, CPI(M), CPI, NCP and BSP public authorities under the RTI Act. It directed them to appoint CPIOs and appellate authorities within six weeks and comply with proactive disclosure obligations under Section 4(1)(b).

Judgment/Order

Date of issue

A Roadmap for the Complaint

3rd June 2013

Judgment given by CIC to bring Political Parties under RTI

3rd June 2013

4) Disclosure of Complaints Against MPs, MLAs and MLCs | 16 July 2012

ADR sought information from the CBI regarding complaints received against MPs, MLAs and MLCs during the preceding ten years, including their disposal and conversion into cases. The CIC observed that although the CBI had subsequently been included in the Second Schedule of the RTI Act, the relevant government notification was issued on 9 June 2011, whereas the RTI application was filed on 2 June 2011. Therefore, the exemption could not apply retrospectively. The CIC directed the CBI to disclose available information within ten working days, including whatever information was available if the complete information could not be provided.

Judgment/Order

Date of issue

CIC Order

16th July 2012

5) Disclosure of Rajya Sabha Members' Pecuniary Interests | 3 June 2011

ADR sought copies of declarations submitted by Rajya Sabha MPs concerning remunerative directorships, shareholdings, paid consultancy and other professional engagements. The CIC observed that disclosure would serve a larger public interest by enabling citizens to monitor potential conflicts between MPs' financial interests and legislative responsibilities. It further held that such disclosure would not constitute an unwarranted invasion of privacy. Accordingly, the CIC directed the Rajya Sabha Secretariat to provide copies of the Register of Members' Interests and relevant documents within ten working days.

Judgment/Order

Date of issue

CIC Order

3rd June 2011

6) Disclosure of Income Tax Returns of Political Parties | 29 April 2008

ADR sought Income Tax Returns and assessment orders of various political parties for the financial years 2002–03 to 2006–07. The CIC observed that transparency in political funding is essential to prevent undisclosed money from influencing democratic institutions. It held that information otherwise exempt from disclosure could be released where larger public interest warrants it. Accordingly, the CIC directed the Income Tax Department to disclose political parties' ITRs and assessment orders within six weeks. However, PAN details were exempted from disclosure due to the possibility of fraudulent misuse.

Judgment/Order

Date of issue

CIC Order

29th April 2008


abc