Skip to main content
Source
Sabrang India
https://sabrangindia.in/declining-assembly-sittings-close-to-zero-participation-by-ruling-bjp-opposition-mp-adr-report/
Author
SABRANGINDIA
Date
Declining sittings in assembly sessions, few questions by MLAs show a disturbing trend in one of India’s large states, Madhya Pradesh, boding ill for both or representative and participative democracy.

Madhya Pradesh, the second largest Indian state by area and the fifth largest state by population with over 72 million residents has seen shorter and shorter sittings of its state assembly that has met on an average for only 16 days a year since 2019. The longest sessions were the 3rd session (July 8 to July 26 2019) and the 8th session (February 22 to March 26, 2021). Both had 13 sittings each.

The highest number of hours contributed for assembly sittings were 116.83 hours in 2019 where assembly had 26 sittings. The lowest number of hours contributed for assembly sittings were 1.53 hours in 2020 where assembly had 4 sittings.

Figure: No. of sittings held in Madhya Pradesh Assembly during the period 2018-2023


Figure: Year Wise Total Time Contributed for Assembly Sessions (in Hours)

The Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR) and Madhya Pradesh Election Watch (MPEW) have through joint RTI applications to the Madhya Pradesh Assembly Secretariat analysed the information received pertaining to the performance of the MLAs and the Legislative Assembly. This report released by ADR and available here, is based on information available on the website of the Madhya Pradesh Legislative Assembly and from the RTI responses received

Analysis of Attendance of MLAs in Madhya Pradesh Legislative Assembly

  • The details of MLAs with highest attendance are given below:
S.No. Name Of the Member Constituency Party Total Sitting Held Attendance Percentage of Attendance
1 Kunwarji Kothar Sarangpur (SC) BJP 79 77 97%
2 Khatik Harishankar Jatara (SC) BJP 79 77 97%
3 Dilip Singh Parihar Neemuch BJP 79 77 97%
4 Shyam Lal Dwivedi Teonthar BJP 79 77 97%
5 Sudesh Rai Sehore BJP 79 77 97%

 Table: MLAs with highest attendance

*15th Session (11th July 2023 to 12th July 2023) 2 Days Attendance data not available on the website at the time of making this report.

Figure: Party Wise Average Attendance
* Including MLAs resigned / elected through Bye –Elections

The ADR has also analysed the number of 1uestions asked by MLAs in the Madhya Pradesh Legislative Assembly; here’s what the information reveals:

  • 235MLAs have asked questions. These MLAs asked a total of 29484
  • The details of top5 MLAs who have asked the highest number of questions are given below.
S.No. Name Of the Member Constituency Party Total Number of Questions Asked
1 Rampal Singh Silwani BJP 390
2 Yashpal Singh Mandsour BJP 387
3 Dr. Hiralal Alawa Manawar (ST) INC 383
4 Umakant Sharma Sironj BJP 381
5 Rajendra Pandey Jaora BJP 377


Despite being in the opposition, the Congress representatives can be observed not raising too many questions in the period. Highest number of Questions were related to Urban Development and Housing, Panchayat And Rural Development, Revenue, School Education and Public Works

Table: Top 5 MLAs who have asked maximum number of questions

 

Figure: Party Wise Average Number of Questions Asked
* Including MLAs resigned/elected through Bye –Elections

Figure: Top 15 – Category Wise Questions Asked

An analysis of the Bills tabled and Bills passed in Madhya Pradesh Legislative Assembly reveals that there were a total of 140 Bills tabled in the 15th Madhya Pradesh Assembly. Out of these 140 Bills, 127(91%) Bills were passed.

Figure: Percentage of Bills Passed in 15th Madhya Pradesh Assembly


abc