One of the smartest things Prime Minister Narendra Modi did after coming to power four years ago was to appoint diehard loyalists as state governors.  They were either beholden to him or to the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) or the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS).

When the Congress was on top of the heap, it routinely shunted disgruntled and rebellious warhorses to Raj Bhavans across the country. In the BJP, if you are senior and disgruntled, you are simply placed in cryogenic care, not swaddled in gubernatorial warmth.

Those constitutional but unelected posts have been paying rich dividends as the BJP moves to a ‘Congress mukt Bharat’.

Also Read: In Hung House, Who Says BJP Man Vajubhai Won’t Help Party Again?

It doesn’t really matter how many seats the BJP ended up with in Karnataka’s hung assembly. The odds are that the BJP will form the next government even if it did not win an outright majority.  What matters is that Karnataka Governor Vajubhai Vala is a Gujarat BJP politician.

In Goa and Manipur last year, and in Meghalaya and Nagaland this year, the BJP has demonstrated that vote shares and seat tallies are academic. The Congress’ decision to hold its enemy closer and offer to prop up a Janata Dal (Secular) ministry headed by HD Kumaraswamy in Karnataka could be just the start of a messy alliance.

Also Read: BJP’s Sway in Karnataka Is Clear – Cong-JDS Govt Won’t Last Long

The Science of Winning Elections

Under Modi and BJP President Amit Shah, the party has replaced the art of elections with the science of winning. It treats every state election like a key battle, down to the last panna pramukh and booth karyakarta. It replenishes its war-chest and opens up with its big-calibre guns on its opponents.

Money is no object: A Centre for Media Studies survey said on Monday that Karnataka 2018 has been the most expensive state election, with between Rs 9,500 and Rs 10,500 crore spent. The state’s chief electoral officer said authorities had seized Rs 94 crore in cash, liquor worth Rs 24.78 crore, and other presumed voter inducements like clothes, vehicles and electronic gadgets worth Rs 66 crore.

Also Read: Karnataka Polls Most Expensive Ever: CMS Survey

It was a ‘squalid, vote-grubbing exercise’, as a character in the BBC serial Yes Minister put it nearly 40 years ago. The Congress badly needs to retain even peripheral power in Karnataka, which has been its main source of funds.  If it is kept out of Karnataka, it will only have Punjab as it tries to pad its coffers for the 2019 general election and key state polls later this year.

A senior Karnataka bureaucrat I spoke with told me corruption in the state was huge and prevails across the board regardless of which party is in power.  A lot of the corruption at the district level has been fed by poor land records. Karnataka politicians are among the country’s richest.

An Association for Democratic Reforms report said the average assets of 184 re-contesting MLAs had risen 64 percent between the 2013 and 2018 assembly elections to Rs 44.24 crore.  The five richest politicians in the state all belong to the Congress party.  The assets of the exiting Energy Minister, DK Shivakumar (who turned 56 on the day he won re-election from the Kanakapura constituency) rose 234 percent during the Siddaramaiah regime to Rs 840 crore.

Also Read: Whom Should Karnataka Guv Invite to Form Govt, BJP or Cong+JD(S)?

The Economy Endures, Whoever Rules

The good news about the Karnataka election is that the state’s economy will continue to do reasonably well, whichever government takes power later this week. Karnataka’s gross state domestic product (GSDP) grew at a compounded annual growth rate (CAGR) of 12.8 percent between 2011 and 2018; GSDP is forecast to grow by 7.42 percent in 2018-19. The state has managed to keep its fiscal deficit below the FRBM target of three percent of GSDP since 2010-11.

This economic performance has taken place despite half of Karnataka’s population depending on agriculture. The state is the most arid in the country after Rajasthan – it has suffered droughts in seven of the past 10 years. Only about 30 percent of its farmland is irrigated.

There is serious farmer distress, although the state is more advanced than any other in linking its agricultural markets on an electronic platform that ensures better price discovery and access to markets for farmers.  Kiran Mazumdar Shaw, chairperson of Biocon Limited, said earlier this month that Karnataka’s entrepreneurial ecosystem has sustained its economy.

“Government engaged very closely with first-generation entrepreneurs in policy-making,” she said. “That is why you have seen that Karnataka has always been ahead in terms of policy-making, whether it is IT policy, biotech policy, start-up policy, electric-vehicle policy – you name it.”

Also Read: Karnataka Election Results: 10 Things To Watch Out For

SM Krishna, Congress Chief Minister between 1999 and 2004, is credited with setting up the Vision Groups of entrepreneurs to help devise policy.  The senior bureaucrat I spoke with said most of the other chief ministers have been dhotiwallahs, more rustic in their roots.  But Mazumdar Shaw said even Siddaramaiah, who hails from the hard-scrabble Kuruba sheep-herding community, had put in a fair bit of infrastructure, including the Bangalore Metro and continued investing in science and technology – steps that would benefit the next government.

Governing parties in Karnataka have changed like clockwork every election – the last time that was different was when Devaraj Urs won re-election in 1978, only to break away from Congress two years later – and there is also the superstition that the same party never rules in both Delhi and Bengaluru.

If the BJP forms the next Karnataka government, it will have to live down the chaos of three chief ministers in five years in its 2008-13 term in power.  The 2018 campaign has seen new lows in abuse and brazen appeals to caste and religion. Whichever side Governor Vala picks, we will have to hold our noses and cheer our latest exhibition of democracy.

Click here for live updates on the Karnataka polls.

(Chaitanya Kalbag is an award-winning journalist and has worked in several countries over more than 43 years. He was Editor, Asia with Reuters News Agency, Editor-in-Chief of Hindustan Times, and Editor at Business Today. He can be followed @chaitanyakalbag on Twitter. This is an opinion piece and the views expressed above are the author’s own. The Quint neither endorses nor is responsible for them.)

© Association for Democratic Reforms
Privacy And Terms Of Use
Donation Payment Method